CCA
Handling Guidelines
Until recently, there were no handling precautions
provided to consumers who purchased or worked with CCA-treated wood.
Only in the last
few months have warning labels begun to be attached to CCA wood products,
after pressure from Senator Bill Nelson and others. Prior to that, little
or no information was available to the general public about the safety hazards
associated with this product.
Now that the safety concerns about CCA-treated wood are becoming widely known,
many consumers and end users of CCA wood products want to know what the risks
are, and what precautions they should take to minimize those risks. They want
answers to questions such as these:
Should
I be concerned about my exposure to CCA wood?
The results of recent
studies indicate that both arsenic and chromium, the toxic chemicals in CCA
wood, leach out of the wood when it is new and as it ages. This means that
some of the chemical may be available on the surface of the wood at any time,
increasing the risk of dermal and other exposures.
But, should we be
concerned about this? Dr. Steve Roberts of the Florida Center for Human and
Environmental Toxicology expressed his concerns about CCA exposure in a recent
report to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, where he stated,
"We tentatively identified 632 m g/100 cm2 as an upper bound estimate
for arsenic concentrations on the skin from dermal contact with CCA wood…
This upper end of the plausible range of exposures is 90 times the [EPA's]
reference dose…. [Because] the risks can vary… we should be concerned about
unrestricted contact with CCA wood."
More importantly,
other studies (Townsend, et al. 2001) indicate that the toxicity of the CCA
chemicals increases as the particle size decreases. This means that
the fine sawdust from CCA wood, which can be generated by sawing, drilling
or sanding, is much more toxic than larger pieces of wood. Thus, exposure
caused by breathing CCA sawdust carries the greatest health risk, especially
if the exposure occurs in an unventilated area. One case that appeared in
the foreign medical journal Acta Pharmacologica et Toxicologica, (Peters,
Croft, Woolson, et al, 1986) described the effects of just such an exposure:
"Case reports were presented of a 42
year old Caucasian woman and a 40 year old man who made picnic tables out
of CCA treated lumber in February and March 1983. A radial arm saw, band saw,
drill press and hand drill were used in a small nonventilated room; no protective
clothing or mask were worn. Within several days, both began to experience
spontaneous nose bleeds, heaviness of the chest, itching and burning of the
skin, and stomach aches. The woman noticed that her hair pulled out when combed.
Other symptoms included alterations in memory and darkening of urine. The
man suffered from severe tarry stools and massive melena, requiring hospitalization
and 7 units of blood. Within 3 months, the symptoms disappeared, but recurred
immediately when they resumed work a year later…"
The
authors of this study concluded that "working with CCA-treated lumber in an
enclosed area appears to pose a very severe health hazard… vigorous measures
should be taken to inform the lumber industy, as well as the general public…
of the special hazard induced by machine-working the freshly-treated lumber,
resulting in a liberation of CCA- loaded sawdust and CCA liquid."
What
precautions should be taken when handling or working with CCA wood?
Several publications
are available from government health departments and environmental agencies,
such as the Connecticut Department of Public Health, the California Department
of Health Services, and the EPA, and these provide helpful precautions for
consumers about handling CCA wood. Also, the Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS)
for CCA-treated wood products and the new CCA Warning Labels provide additional
information about handling CCA wood.
The following is a summary of those precautions, derived from these assorted
sources:
1.
Wear gloves made of a material such as rubber, which is resistant to chemicals
such as arsenic when handling CCA treated wood. (Source: Cal HESIS Fact Sheet)
2. When sanding, sawing or drilling, wear goggles to protect your eyes from
flying CCA sawdust. Dust masks or pesticide-rated respirators should
also be worn when sawing or sanding CCA wood, to protect your lungs.
3. Wear work clothes when working with CCA, and wash them separately. (Source:
Cal HESIS Fact Sheet)
4. After working with CCA, wash yourself thoroughly before eating, drinking
or smoking. (Source: Cal HESIS Fact Sheet)
5. DO NOT burn treated wood in open fires, or in stoves, fireplaces, or boilers.
[Editor's note: This can release extremely toxic vapors of arsine gas.]
(Source: New CCA Warning Label)
6. DO NOT handle freshly-treated "wet" CCA-treated lumber. (Source:
Osmose MSDS)
7. Perform the work outdoors on a dropcloth so that sawdust can be collected
and discarded. (Source: Conn. Dept. of Public Health Fact Sheet)
8. DO NOT use treated wood for mulch, cutting boards, counter tops, beehives,
animal bedding, or structures or containers for storing animal feed or human
food. (Source: New CCA Warning Label) [Editor's note: How about picnic
tables??]
9. DO NOT use where treated wood may come into direct or indirect contact
with drinking water. (Source: New CCA Warning Label)
10. DO NOT eat edible plants [grown] near CCA-treated decks. (Source: Conn.
Dept. of Public Health Fact Sheet)
11. Keep children and pets out of under-deck areas where arsenic may have
leached in the past. (Source: Conn. Dept. of Public Health Fact Sheet)
12. Install a plastic liner on the inside of CCA-treated boards used to frame
garden beds. (Source: Conn. Dept. of Public Health Fact Sheet)
[Editor's
note: Better yet, do not use CCA wood to frame your garden beds!]
13. Individuals with pre-existing disease or a history of ailments involving
the skin, kidney, liver, respiratory tract, eyes or nervous system are at
a greater risk of developing adverse effects from woodworking operations with
this product. (Source: Osmose MSDS) [Editor's note: this is quite a damning
statement, taken straight from the Material Safety Data Sheet published by
the manufacturer of CCA lumber products.]
What
precautions should be taken with regard to existing CCA wood structures, such
as decks and playground equipment?
CCA-treated wood decks are
a great concern for most consumers, as they are more common, take up a larger
surface area, and are a valuable asset to the homeowner. For these reasons,
it has not been recommended that owners tear down their decks. In some
cases doing so might actually increase exposure to CCA. Instead, as the Connecticut
Department of Public Health has recommended, consumers should "seal existing
CCA-treated structures (decks, playscapes) every 2 years with a sealant such
as an oil-based stain". Latex-based deck paint may also be suitable in
coating and sealing the wood to prevent CCA from leaching to the surface.
Should
I get rid of my CCA-treated wood products?
It
is advisable that owners of CCA wood picnic tables either dispose of these
items, or return them to the store where they were purchased and ask for a
refund. Logic dictates that if CCA wood is not safe enough for use as a cutting
board, (see details above), then it is not safe enough for use in picnic tables
either. Hopefully, the retailers will refund the original purchase price of
the item.
CCA lumber, scrap and posts that are being stockpiled should be disposed of
as soon as possible. Alternative wood products which are arsenic and chromium-free
are now available in some locations to replace CCA-treated wood.
County, city and state governments have to be more cautious with regard to
CCA wood. Because of this, many have already torn down existing CCA playground
structures, even removing as much as 1 foot of soil around the equipment to
ensure that the CCA leachate in the soil is also removed. The expense for
doing this kind of remediation is substantial, and is well beyond the means
of the typical homeowner. For this and other reasons, CCA is now prohibited
from use in future building projects in several communities in Florida.
What
is the proper way to dispose of scrap CCA wood?
It
is important to remember that CCA products would be classified as hazardous
waste, if it were not for a special exemption. Therefore, CCA-treated wood
should ALWAYS be disposed in a municipal landfill. There the wood will be
stored and sorted, segregated from other recyclable lumber.
CCA wood should NEVER BE BURNED, since this frees the arsenic in the form
of a toxic gas. Also, the leftover ash is laden with arsenic and is highly
toxic.
For the time being, disposal of CCA wood does not incur any environmental
impact fees. However, it is foreseeable that as the ever-increasing burden
of CCA wood disposal is imposed on
municipalities and landfill owners, impact fees may be required to fund the
disposal costs. (For more details, see the section on CCA Disposal Issues.)
Consumers may want to stay ahead of these future fees by 1) disposing of existing
CCA wood that they currently have stockpiled, and 2)replacing any CCA structures
in need of repair with alternative treated wood products as they become available.
Back
to Top
©Copyright
2002 BANCCA.ORG, LLC
All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer:
BANCCA.ORG makes every effort to ensure the accuracy
of the information provided on its Web site. However the information presented
is for research and educational purposes only, and is subject to regular review
and change without notice. No warranty or representation can be provided regarding
this information. We do not accept liability for any losses or damage arising
directly or indirectly from reliance on the information in any article written
or published on this Web site.